Ethical dilemmas in genetic patenting

Do we encourage more research into more beneficial areas of science by the incentive system of patents than we would by not having patents. Such underlying complexity of views regarding genetic engineering makes the setting of ethical limits difficult to achieve, or indeed, even discuss.

Ethically we may question the length of patents in such tight races by companies with the greatest money, when they have the potential to monopolise numerous genomes.

Patenting Genetic Material

The UPOV Convention governs an alternative system of intellectual property called plant variety rights, which allows the breeder to market the crop variety as long as they can provide seed at reasonable price to all.

Conclusion While respect for autonomy suggests some self-interests must be considered for the sake of researchers' autonomy and their future work, most rapid progress will be obtained if data is shared between all researchers.

The following sections detail some of the issues that have arisen during the peer-driven guidelines development process and associated impact analysis consultations carried out by the CCAC.

The Illusion of Improving Human Beings Although eugenics of this type is more of the stuff of science fiction than any likely reality, a question to be raised is at what point would we pass from a genuine somatic gene therapy into cosmetic improvement.


Let us reflect further on how a possible further Bioethics Convention could meet the challenges that ethical patenting faces from biotechnology. Economic and ethics in the genetic engineering of animals. There is often a gulf of trust and communication as well as in understanding. However, before accepting the results in terms of a measure of Nobel Prizes, or patent applications, we should consider how products of traditional agriculture and medicine have been applied to provide the introductions for current agricultural and pharmaceutical applications of biotechnology.

Ethical Issues in Genetic Engineering and Transgenics

In practice it may not matter, since it is hard to see on what basis it could ever be decided that a scientific evaluation of the risk was now possible. However, the genomics companies like TIGR have applied for patents on previously published sequences from databases, and the policy seems to be emerging.

The mule is a common example of a transgenic organism created when a horse and a donkey mate and produce offspring.

Genetics and Ethics

Therefore there is an existing precedent for exemption from property ownership, which is the point of the exclusiveness of patents, when some property is of great benefit to the public. However, there is an existing difference in the protection of property rights compared with other rights in international law and declarations of human rights.

These concepts seem intuitively to be more sustainable than the current linear economic system. Eubios Ethics Institute, For example, when an electric current passes through a resistor like a kettle the electrical energy is converted to heat energy, and the energy used is potential difference volts X current amps X time.

Another argument people give to promote research is that of national pride, that people want those of other countries to have a high opinion of their country.

Policymaking aspects", in Genetics, Ethics and Human Values: However, the scale of clandestine applications could only be limited, without public disclosure and resulting outcry. To shed light on the big picture, explorer and sustainability campaigner Jason Lewis has drawn parallels to other, more tangible closed systems.

Another basic distortion is the tendency to evaluate all things in a material and economic frame of reference, seeing the potential of genetics primarily in terms of a means of economic gain and the power that goes with it, as though these were the supreme integration points for human activity, rather than seeing them within the wider framework of divine and human relationships.

However, before accepting the results in terms of a measure of Nobel Prizes, or patent applications, we should consider how products of traditional agriculture and medicine have been applied to provide the introductions for current agricultural and pharmaceutical applications of biotechnology.

With the exception of a couple of isolated cases, the genetically engineered pet industry is yet to move forward.

Ethical issues in patenting scientific research pp. Many people are also concerned that clones would be produced with a specific need and purpose in mind and such cloned individuals would be traded or sold, amounting to human trafficking which is illegal.

In the case of natural products there are often difficulties because many groups may have published progressive details of a molecule or sequence, so it may have lost its novelty and nonobviousness.

There is always a risk involved. There is public rejection of the idea of patenting animals in many countries, as seen in the International Bioethics Survey I conducted in in ten countries in Asia-Pacific Macer, This issue has been used by industry to oppose moves to block patents on biotechnological inventions that come from other ethical concerns Ballmaier, ; Macer, Food and Drug Administration FDA has banned xenotransplantation trials using nonhuman primates until the procedures have been adequately demonstrated to be safe and until ethical issues have been sufficiently publicly discussed.

Conversely, however, there is an ethical duty to fund science placed on all countries. Moreover, by definition, it would be difficult to identify which were generational effects that had resulted from the therapy. Ethical Dilemmas in Genetic Patenting – A Utilitarian Perspective On August 16th, the U.S.

Federal Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that Myriad Genetics in Salt Lake City, Utah, had the right to patent ‘isolated’ genes that are linked to ovarian and breast cancers.1 This means that Myriad Genetics can prevent others from using the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes in research.

The issues that affect the biotechnology industry include inter alia discoveries, and related to genetics, such as the patentability of genetic information, the conduct of clinical research involving gene therapy, the approval process for new drugs, proteins and other biological components, genetic.

Moral and Ethical Issues in Gene Therapy. Published: Apr 14, Introduction. Genetic research has advanced in a dramatic fashion in the last decade or so, to the point where it has now become possible to attempt therapeutic genetic modification, in a few cases of human genes, where a defects exists which manifests itself in certain serious diseases.

The key insight came from a particularly nasty bug—the one that causes strep throat. Its Crispr system made two RNA sequences that attached to a clam-shaped endonuclease called Cas9.

The Clone Age: Adventures in the New World of Reproductive Technology;Adventures in the New World of Reproductive Techniques [Lori B. Andrews] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.

Patenting of Human Genes: Moral and Ethical Issues

A groundbreaking and provocative book, exploring the ramifications of test tube babies. The resolution of all these ethical dilemmas is limited only by our moral imagination. The only thing we can't do is ignore the ethical dimension of patenting human life.

Miriam Schulman is the director of communications for the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics.

Ethical dilemmas in genetic patenting
Rated 3/5 based on 65 review
Patenting Genetic Material | The Basics of Genetic Engineering